Archive du forum du MOOC Recherche Reproductible Session 2

Computational document evaluation

MelissaSMW

I was evaluating the first document but when i was going to fill out the spaces it changed and now it gives me a different one to evaluate. I’d like to complete the form for the evaluation of the first one, since I’va already checked it. Is there any way it could be reassigned to me?

Melissa

lfarhi

Hello Melissa,
I will notice this bug to the FUN plateform but I think that it’s too late for your problem.
Sorry, you will have to correct another copy.
Could you just explain what exactly happened ? Did you refresh for exemple the web page ?

MelissaSMW

Yes, I had already started the evaluation and i had come back to the same link a couple times because it was an R docuemnt and I was trying to understand it (I was reading how some of the functions used worked). Anyway, I’d already closed and opened the FUN page several times, always returning to the same document, and yesterday afternoon when i finished reproducing it and was ready to write the evaluation, the student student changed, it’s even a different path and different problem. I understand it might not be possibe to get the other one back, you suggest I shouldn’t open and close it? I have the same one from yesterday today and I closed the platform last night.

Melissa

lfarhi

Thanks for all this explanations. I have to inform the FUN plateform about your problem because I didn’t know that it was possible to loose a peer evaluation. It might be because it took time for you to correct the document but you should have enough time to read the document and enter your evaluation.
I will ask to the FUN plateform what is the maximum time limit to correct a document before you loose it. I’ll inform you as soon as possible about the real rules, sorry for that.
Best regards

MelissaSMW

Ok, thank you very much
Actually the one I had before showed up again and the “new” one is gone. I evaluated it and will try to keep the tab open while I evaluate the next one it has given me.
Melissa

CharlesMagne

I had the same problem. I received Christophe Pouzat’s org analysis to evaluate. He used gnuplot in his analysis which was not described in the MOOC (I recently posted a forum comment on the subject). By the time I figured out gnuplot and finished the evaluation, I was no longer able to fill in the evaluation form on the FUN platform ( I had not refreshed the form, but it was a day later). Instead, I was asked to evaluate a project that I had already evaluation !
It would be useful in the future to explicitly state the time limits for completing the evaluation before the platform blocks you and forces you to start over.

Kujyto

I have another problem with the evaluation of my submission: I think I received the evaluation of another submission.

I did the subject 3 (cholera epidemic) but the comments of one of the peers are about separating the two phenomena, which correspond to subject 1 (CO2 concentration).

Is there a way to rebind the evaluation to the right submission?

lfarhi

I still have no answer from the FUN platform but I will inform you as soon as possible about this delay.

lfarhi

Don’t worry, the teachers of the Mooc will evaluate the documents which had a problem during correction.
@charlesMagne, I note that your copy had an evaluation problem.

CharlesMagne

No need for me- I finished my evaluations. I was thinking that it would be useful for the future repetitions of the MOOC. Thank you for this excellent MOOC and the quick responses of the team to questions on the forum.

CharlesMagne

My copy had an evaluation problem ? Pas grave en tout cas.

lfarhi

I will check at the end

lfarhi

Hello @Kujyto
The teachers will correct your copy.

lfarhi

ok @CharlesMagne, I note that there were no problem with evaluation of your document, thank you

alvin38

Hi Kujyto,

Done. I’ve just reevaluted your submission. Excellent job by the way!

Best,

Arnaud

Kujyto

Thank you, but the evaluation I received will maybe be missing for the right recipient: the evaluation contains good and precise comments.

Best

lfarhi

Don’t worry, when the period of evaluation will be finished (June, 14), only the evaluation of @alvin38 will be taken into account.

lfarhi

Hello,
Today, I received the full explanation of this problem of “lost copy” from the FUN platform.
Actually, when you go to the correction interface, you have 8 hours to correct the document after which another copy will be allocated to you.
Sorry, we don’t have a hand in this period which could be short for those who want to correct during several days.